Lawmakers Assert That Addressing Human Rights Concerns in India Strengthens, Not Undermines, US Relations

HI INDIA NEWS DESK

WASHINGTON, D.C. – Indian American lawmakers emphasized their commitment to addressing human rights issues in India but noted that lecturing New Delhi on the matter is counterproductive. Instead, they advocated for a dialogue with Indian leaders to express their concerns constructively.

At the “Desi Decides” Summit of Indian American Impact on May 16, Congressman Ro Khanna, co-chair of the Congressional India Caucus, highlighted the need for a nuanced approach.

Joining Khanna in the panel discussion were lawmakers Shri Thanedar, Pramila Jayapal, and Dr. Ami Bera. Moderated by ABC national correspondent Zohreen Shah, the discussion touched on Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s relations with India’s Muslims.

Khanna suggested a more constructive approach: “Having a conversation about the imperfections in our democracy and India’s, and how to collectively advance democracy and human rights, is more productive.”

Bera echoed Khanna’s sentiments, stressing the importance of India’s secular nature. “If India loses its secular identity, it changes its essence and global perception,” Bera said. He also expressed concerns about press freedom and the viability of opposition in India. “A vibrant democracy requires freedom of speech, press, and opposition. I hope India’s democracy remains robust,” he added.

Pramila Jayapal agreed with Bera and Khanna, underscoring the responsibility to critique both domestic and international issues. “We shouldn’t lecture, but we must consider all U.S. interests, including values like freedom of religion and press,” Jayapal stated. She stressed that raising concerns about human rights aligns with American values and does not undermine U.S.-India relations.

Shri Thanedar supported a strong U.S.-India partnership, urging India to solidify its commitment to the U.S. “India should recognize its economic power and role in countering China’s aggression,” he added.