Delhi HC rejects plea against publishing novelisation of screenplay of Ray’s ‘Nayak’

Delhi HC rejects plea against publishing novelisation of screenplay of Ray’s ‘Nayak’May 23, 2023New Delhi, May 23 (IANS) The Delhi High Court on Tuesday rejected a plea moved by the producers of the 1966 Bengali film ‘Nayak’, R.D.B and Co., seeking injunction against publishing house HarperCollins from printing the novelisation of the films screenplay.Directed by iconic filmmaker late Satyajit Ray, ‘Nayak’ starring Uttam Kumar and Sharmila Tagore in lead roles was Ray’s second entirely original screenplay after Kanchenjungha (1962).Justice C. Hari Shankar, while rejecting the plea, said that the first owner of copyright in ‘Nayak’ was Ray who wrote the screenplay for the movie, and he had the right to novelise the screenplay. However, consequent on his demise, that right could be assigned to his son (Sandip Ray) and others on whom the right devolved.”As the first owner of the copyright in the screenplay of the film ‘Nayak’, therefore, the right to novelise the screenplay also vested in Satyajit Ray. That right could be assigned by him – and, consequent on his demise, by his son and others on whom the right devolved – on any other person, under Section 18(1)44 of the Copyright Act,” the court said.”The assignment of the right to novelise the screenplay of the film ‘Nayak’, by Sandip Ray and the SPSRA, in favour of the defendant is, therefore, wholly in order and in accordance with the provisions of the Act. On the other hand, the assertion, by the plaintiff, of the copyright in the screenplay of the film ‘Nayak’ is unsupported by any provision in the Act and is, in fact, in violation of the provisions which have been referred to hereinabove,” the court said.R.D.B. and Co. had approached the high court stating that Ray was commissioned by R.D. Banshal (of R.D.B. and Co.) to write the screenplay of the film.The novel was published by HarperCollins on May 5, 2018 after it was novelised by Bhaskar Chattopadhyay.”The plaintiff claimed that the novelisation of the screenplay by Bhaskar Chattopadhyay and the publication of the novel by the defendant, constituted infringement of their copyright within the meaning of Section 51 of the Copyright Act,” the court noted.”Proviso (b) to Section 17, in its plain terms, refers, insofar as cinematograph films are concerned, with the making of a cinematograph film for valuable consideration at the instance of any person,” the court said.Justice Shankar held that Ray, as the author of the screenplay of ‘Nayak’, was the first owner of the copyright in the said film. “Therefore, the contention that the producer is the owner of the copyright of the screenplay cannot be accepted,” the court ruled.”For the aforesaid discussion, the plaintiff has no right whatsoever, in law, to injunct the defendant from novelising the screenplay of the film ‘Nayak’,” the court noted.–IANSspr/arm